top of page

Is Instagram still worth it as a creative in 2026? My honest take as an Instapoet.

7 hours ago
5 min read

Is Instagram still worth it as a creative in 2026? My honest take as an Instapoet.


Instagram is where it all started for me, 5 years ago. One brave moment grew into an unexpected journey of writing and sharing my work online. Back in 2021, Instagram was well known for its supportive creative communities, so I followed my fellow creatives to the platform.  A plus was that I didn’t have a personal account, which created a safe distance between myself and the people who knew me in real life. It felt like a haven where my creative writing could grow.


Over the years, Instagram started to feel different, and that had everything to do with TikTok joining the social media platforms. 


Short-form video (Reels) became the main focus of the platform, while regular posts faded into the background. Not only did this shift change how creatives displayed their work, but it also meant the coming of “catchy hooks”, “trending audio,” and “chasing a viral concept”.


Creatives needed to adjust, and suddenly we all needed to be “Influencers” or “Social media specialists” and “Marketers” to get our work seen outside of our followers. To grow meant posting every single day with the right hashtags, a good hook, a trending song, and hoping it would catch a wave on the algorithm.


Meanwhile, our feeds were drowned with ads, suggestions, recommendations, and more ads.  This created a rift between you and your following. You no longer had a curated feed. It became chaos to read through instead. After users complained, they added the option to switch between feeds. One still showed suggestions while the other showed only your followers (and ads). Later on, even the hashtags, which were a big part of being able to be found, became irrelevant, and everyone changed to adding keywords to their captions instead. Adding “being an SEO- expert” to the required job list.


Subscriptions started rolling out.


For 15 euro/ a month, you could have an ad-free feed. For a little more money, you could even get the verified badge. After every post, you would get messages to boost your post further into the algorithm, at a cost, of course.  To convince you that it was all worth it, they would praise you with false positive feedback and badges. They claimed your post did better than the last, but the analytics hardly backed that up. When they limit your reach, that one post performing better than the previous one becomes a selling hook.


The rift between creatives and their own followers grew. Reach became limited, and you were lucky to reach 10 to 15 percent of your followers whenever you posted something new. When Meta One rolled out, it became clear that Instagram had become a pay-to-play platform.  Reach got only worse, and most people felt like they had put a (pay)wall between them and their community unless you paid, and even then reach was not optimal.


A neon light with a heart and zero likes next to from Instagram
Photo source: Unsplash

And then there was Meta AI.


Once Meta AI rolled out across the Meta platforms, it became clear Instagram was no longer a safe space for creative work. In 2025, the first wave of updates claimed your “public posts” could be used to train their AI model. They offered only an “Opt-out” in Europe because of European Privacy laws. I signed the “Opt-out” but also read the fine print. If your post was reposted on a public profile that hadn’t signed the “opt-out”, it could potentially still be used for AI training.


I became very aware of how Meta stayed vague about what was protected and what was not, and only a few months later, reposts happened. Resharing a post to other accounts became a way to gain visibility. A visibility that blurred the lines of the “Opt-out” even more.


A year later (October 2026), Meta announced another update. Links shared on your profile would be crawled to analyse the linked sites, and the information gathered would then be used to train their AI (only on business and creator accounts). They were moving off-platform, wanting even more data from their users.


People started talking about signing the Opt-out from 2025 to protect everything from AI (which clearly stated an end date when the update went into effect in 2025 ). Many also believed adding a Linktree would stop crawlers, but Linktree is a public platform and doesn’t prevent crawlers. You can only stop crawlers by disabling them in your website settings, or switching to a personal account instead of a creator/business account.


It became obvious Meta was pushing AI through and wanted to take everything they could get their hands on. It felt like being in a toxic relationship, and so I made my account private, because that is the only way to keep your creative work safe.


There are more issues about Instagram that made me take a step back, like


  • Censorship,

  • loss of ownership of content and creative work,

  • ethical issues around data centers and political interference,

  • no protection for its users,

  • and sudden unjustified bans of profiles.


Instagram wanted us to stay because of years of dedication and followers we built, but trust goes both ways, and now it feels like a one-sided relationship. We deserve better; our work deserves better than to be used as a product for AI.


There are plenty of alternative safe spaces for your creative work. They might not have as many users as Instagram yet, but a big market does not mean more visibility.  The right market will get you there instead. I am currently only posting my poetry on Substack. Where I found like-minded creatives who want to support and read your creative work. Substack feels more like an honest space because people there actually want to read and not just consume.


In the end


Am I gone forever? Probably not, because the communities on Instagram have become family. Stepping away from Instagram is more about safeguarding my work than a surrender. I’m already looking for creative ways to turn my Instagram into a creative hub inside the community without having to share my poetry. Because being a creative means finding creative ways to get our work out into the open world. And I believe Instagram can still be a part of that.


In the end, our work deserves a home that values our efforts as creatives. And as a creative, we deserve a safe space that honors the trust we place in them.


I hope this post was helpful and brought some insight into the platform because so many creatives tend to blame their work for not getting an audience while it mostly likeky reason is the platform itself. So keep creating and doing what brings you joy. Find ways to still bring it into this world because more than ever are we in need of human-made art.


Thank you for reading and perhaps consider joining my free monthly newsletter to stay updated on upcoming posts, events, and all things poetry.




Ps: This is how I experienced and viewed my own creative journey on Instagram.


Comments


bottom of page